fbpx
Skip to main content

MIDI Forum

So where are the RE...
 
Notifications
Clear all

So where are the REAL specifications for MIDI?

20 Posts
13 Users
0 Reactions
11.1 K Views
Josh Mayfield
Posts: 2
New Member
Topic starter
 

So I just visited the site in light of the new "MIDI Association" changes, and I'm really confused. There's a whole "Specs" section that has what it claims is the "Complete MIDI 1.0 Detailed Specification" however the content listed there in no way comprises the complete MIDI specification. There are lists of controller numbers and message IDs, but there's nothing about timing considerations, actual message format, or even a basic summary of how the MIDI protocol works.

So where are the actual downloadable MIDI specifications?

In the member's portal, there's a Document Downloads page, but the only thing listed there is a "MIDI Manufacturers Association Membership Form." But no other downloads. The form itself is an application that involves annual dues. So, I'm guessing this means that even though I have a user account at MIDI.org, and I can visit my "Member's Portal" I'm not an actual member, right? (In which case, what is the point of creating an account at the site?)

 
Posted : 26/01/2016 7:44 am
The MIDI Association
Posts: 100
Admin Registered
 

Hi Josh,

You are right the core MIDI 1.0 spec is not up in the site yet.

We wanted to get the site up before NAMM , but we knew it wasn't 100% complete. We will be working on re-doing the spec area and making all the MIDI documents available for download at no charge to members as both individual files and as Zip files with multiple files bound together.

You are a registered member as only members can post on the forum. We'd ask your patience for a bit as we recover from NAMM and start work on improving the spec section. We know that in a few weeks, we will be able to provide much better access to the specs than was previously available, but to get it right will take a bit of time.

There are a lot documents and we want to make sure they are organized correctly and easy to search and download.

 
Posted : 26/01/2016 8:07 am
dslsynth
Posts: 5
Active Member
 

Just wanted to say thanks a thousands for making the MIDI specifications available to the general public. Progressing away from purchased books and towards digital documents freely available to signed up members is a HUGE STEP FORWARD for the global MIDI community. Thanks a lot for that!

 
Posted : 26/01/2016 10:32 am
Josh Mayfield
Posts: 2
New Member
Topic starter
 

The MIDI Association wrote:

You are right the core MIDI 1.0 spec is not up in the site yet.
...
We wanted to get the site up before NAMM...

That's completely understandable. I'm glad to know that the specs will eventually be downloadable from the site.

I had been planning to order the specs sometime this year (assuming I'd be purchasing the printed copy from the old site like you mentioned), and it's good to know I'll be able to save sixty bucks and not have to sacrifice my limited shelf space for a printed spec, when I'd prefer an electronic version anyway.

Thanks!

 
Posted : 26/01/2016 10:43 am
Paul Linington
Posts: 1
New Member
 

I'm looking forward to the download. I've never understood why it has always been so difficult to get a copy of the spec.

 
Posted : 29/01/2016 12:37 pm
Yannick Duchêne
Posts: 12
Active Member
 

After some web pages, in the past, it use to be as low as $2 in the late 80's, so I believe the $60 was more likely for funding the MIDI association than manual processing and snail‑mail (personally, not free as in beer is not an issue to me, but $60 was too high).

[Ed: The MIDI Specification is not a single document, but dozens of different documents, some that modify earlier documents, some that add to them. Many of the documents were published before the internet even existed, so were only ever available in print. All of the printed documents were compiled into one document in 1996 which was over 300 pages, and sold for $60. -MMA]

 
Posted : 27/02/2016 10:55 am
Bob Lee
Posts: 12
Active Member
 

Here's a scan PDF of it. You can't search because it's just images of the pages, but it's still useful.

[Ed: This URL has been removed because the MIDI Spec is a copyrighted document and the poster does not have permission of the copyright owner to provide the document.- MMA]

 
Posted : 27/02/2016 12:26 pm
Yannick Duchêne
Posts: 12
Active Member
 

[…]
[Ed: The MIDI Specification is not a single document, but dozens of different documents, some that modify earlier documents, some that add to them. Many of the documents were published before the internet even existed, so were only ever available in print. All of the printed documents were compiled into one document in 1996 which was over 300 pages, and sold for $60. -MMA]

Oh, thanks, I was not suspecting this was a so big document (I planned to order it as a used-book on an on‑line store, but never did so far). So what's on the web since years, must be overly simplified (while seemingly enough to parse and interpret typical MIDI files).

@Bob Lee: what have you tried to do … silly of you 😮 🙂 .

 
Posted : 27/02/2016 2:16 pm
MMA
 MMA
Posts: 25
Admin Registered
 

Yannick,

The documents you can find on the web are generally 20 or more years old. Since then we have added many new messages and defined many "recommended practices" (ways to use the MIDI messages in products so that they work well together) which we described on our previous website, and will eventually describe here as well. Since we have tried very hard not to change any definitions once they have been published, the information on the web about MIDI is generally accurate, but it is not always complete. Newer documents (supplements) describe additional ways to do things in MIDI that have been standardized, and also may correct some explanations that were not always clear, so the later MMA documents are very useful for improving product compatibility.

Forum Admin
MMA

 
Posted : 27/02/2016 3:09 pm
Bob Lee
Posts: 12
Active Member
 

I'm writing code for a 1988 synth, so the "best practices" from the 1995 version of the spec work well for me.

 
Posted : 27/02/2016 4:50 pm
Jan Kučera
Posts: 17
Eminent Member
 

Is there any update on the progress of making the specs available?

 
Posted : 29/03/2016 6:29 am
MMA
 MMA
Posts: 25
Admin Registered
 

Is there any update on the progress of making the specs available?

No, there won't be anything new to say until the specs are available... we're still working on it.

Forum Admin
MMA

 
Posted : 29/03/2016 8:34 am
Yannick Duchêne
Posts: 12
Active Member
 

So, best wishes (I don't know how English people would say, we would say « bon courage », in French).

 
Posted : 29/03/2016 10:18 am
Bavi_H
Posts: 266
Reputable Member
 

At the bottom of this page: The Complete MIDI 1.0 Detailed Specification, I noticed there is now a link to "Download the Complete MIDI 1.0 Detailed Specification Document (1996)", but the link gets "404 Page not found".

@MMA, I'm confused, has the specification been made available? I don't remember that download link being there earlier in the year.

(Actually, it looks like every document link on the site gets "404 Page not found". Something seems wrong.)

 
Posted : 22/05/2016 5:46 pm
JohnG
Posts: 225
Estimable Member
 

Correct, I'm finding that too.

They were there a short while back, but now I'm getting the same error 404 when trying to download either the main spec. or any of the RP's and CA's.
Fortunately I managed to download most of what I needed when they were on line.

Can we report a broken link?

 
Posted : 23/05/2016 12:32 am
Page 1 / 2
Share: