I've run across a hand full of GS MIDI files that are crashing my editor because the values in the percussion assignment SYSEX commands are not within the bounds expected.
To my knowledge, GS assigns custom percussion channels using
F0 0A 41 (10) 42 12 40 1x 15 0y 0F F7
where "x" is the "part number".
However, in these particular files (SC-88Pro midi collection), I am seeing
F0 41 10 42 12 40 03 15 00 28 F7 <---
F0 41 10 42 12 40 10 15 01 1A F7
etc
So when I do the part number byte (0x1x) - 0xF, I'm getting negative values, because it is 0x instead of 1x.
I'm curious if anyone can shed some light on this. Even in the manual specifically for the SC-88Pro, it says...
[EDIT]
** The 03 in the SYSEX above is actually EFX Parameter 19 in the SC-88Pro SYSEX table, meaning that I need to be more narrow in my check of that field, and only accept the value as a percussion part number if it is between 10 and 1F. Currently (or previously by the time you read this) I check the value, and assume it is always going to be 1x, when it can actually be 0x, 1x, 2x, or 4x (at least with the SC-88Pro).
To my knowledge, GS assigns custom percussion channels using
F0 0A 41 (10) 42 12 40 1x 15 0y 0F F7
where "x" is the "part number".
However, in these particular files (SC-88Pro midi collection), I am seeing
F0 41 10 42 12 40 03 15 00 28 F7 <---
F0 41 10 42 12 40 10 15 01 1A F7
etc
So when I do the part number byte (0x1x) - 0xF, I'm getting negative values, because it is 0x instead of 1x.
I'm curious if anyone can shed some light on this. Even in the manual specifically for the SC-88Pro, it says...
[EDIT]
** The 03 in the SYSEX above is actually EFX Parameter 19 in the SC-88Pro SYSEX table, meaning that I need to be more narrow in my check of that field, and only accept the value as a percussion part number if it is between 10 and 1F. Currently (or previously by the time you read this) I check the value, and assume it is always going to be 1x, when it can actually be 0x, 1x, 2x, or 4x (at least with the SC-88Pro).
Jason
set the type of the post as
Technical Question — 1 year ago
0
Undo
Votes
where "x" is the "part number".
Careful, this is not accurate for the Sound Canvas.
"x" represents a "block" where block 0 (00h) is Part 10, block 1-9 (01h-09h) is part 1-9 and block 10-15 (0Ah-0Fh) is part 11-16.
where "x" is the "part number".
Careful, this is not accurate for the Sound Canvas.
"x" represents a "block" where block 0 (00h) is Part 10, block 1-9 (01h-09h) is part 1-9 and block 10-15 (0Ah-0Fh) is part 11-16.
Yes, I was aware of this. However, I apparently never properly implemented it prior to yesterday
After I sorted out the "not always 1x" testing, I had a file where my program flagged Channel 1 as percussion, as well as 10 and 11. Yet channel 1 was named "Piano". I checked my code, and sure enough, I had just put it in 0-F order, even though in my comments I had it listed correctly as 0=10, 1-9 = 1-9, and A-F = 11-16. - Page :
- 1
There are no replies made for this post yet.
